California's Proposition 187 & Geo-Cultural Concerns   Term Paper ID:27469 Click to get this paper

Essay Subject: Describes the geo-cultural issues involved in the current immigration debate. Focuses on California & Prop. 187, but implies a more generalized conclusion.... More...

6 Pages / 1350 Words 4 sources, 7 Citations, APA Format $48.00 Return to List of Papers

Paper Abstract: Describes the geo-cultural issues involved in the current immigration debate. Focuses on California & Prop. 187, but implies a more generalized conclusion. Paper Introduction: Background A portion of elite opinion in the United States has taken a strong stand against what they label as "immigrant-baiting." For example, Business Week (Oct. 14, 1996) has argued that it is as loathsome as race-baiting and is often used for ugly political purposes. The magazine believes that stigmatizing immigrants cannot be tolerated. A think-tank in the state of California released a comprehensive report entitled "Why They Count: Immigrants Contributions to the Golden State." This report was intended to address the rising tide of anti-immigrant sentiment in the state of California through the presentation of what the report labeled as factual and education information on the historical and modern-day contributions of California immigrants Text of the Paper: The entire text of the paper is shown below. However, the text is somewhat scrambled. We want to give you as much information as we possibly can about our papers and essays, but we cannot give them away for free. In the text below you will find that while disordered, many of the phrases are essentially intact. From this text you will be able to get a solid sense of the writing style, the concepts addressed, and the sources used in the research paper. argued that it is as loathsome as race-baiting entitled Why TheyCount Immigrants Contributions to asfactual and education information on the given current levels of economic growth and corresponding resourcesavailable to critical geopolitical perspective the issue sectors ofelite public opinion While which new membership in any community society or even Taken this analysis itwill also case highly arbitrary ones it is race as might have been thecase with composition irrespective of the assimilability communities can readily accommodate or are on or selection criteria for new in general Unfortunately some segments of elite opinion outside of legality altogether Business spirit freedom of travel appears as an inalienable standing or consideration of prior political or even criminalrecords a state agnosticism on immigration would also tend to immigrants In contrast current policy by distinguishingbetween met some criteria in order to racist does seem to implicitly legitimate illegalimmigration and thus plight of illegal immigrants this does whatever provisions are mandated for concept of legality and consequently the social system public agencies providing social servicesinto extensions common identity As was argued earlier or society is defined implies the terms on which a privileged legal status which as scapegoats November New Republic Editorial Huntington S against what they label as tolerated A think-tank inthe state of of anti-immigrant sentiment in thestate of California been framed by concern over the abilityof the nation asoverheated rhetoric that treated illegal the economicand social dimensions touched upon in ofnewcomers that can be integrated without causing considerable dysfunctions Huntington The discussion which follows will attempt to that as long as there are national Such criteria could indeed be racist ifthey excluded interests in keeping wagerate low by inflating the available labor insisting on the cultural assimilability ofnewcomers and their children or isever proper for a community or society its undesirability as law but nevertheless should be illegal and thatall immigration it should not restrict any should be obliged to eliminate any barriers to mobility orcommunity simply get the government out of the business of Such a position also seems accord a privileged status to thoseborn commonality in community membership isachieved Legality and Illegality To oppose laudable to argue for compassion immigrants are in fact in the country illegally abolishing qualifying criteria the same cannot be said as it is actually formulated In social services However such propositions do assumecorrectlythat citizenship citizens in constructing social and political entities It assumes correctly that citizens Urban perspective Immigration inCalifornia then and now Los Angeles immigrants October Business Week Editorial Background A portion of elite and is often used for the Golden State This report historical and modern-daycontributions of California immigrants Aubry The support additional immigrants Finally an ofimmigration policy and specifically the passage of proposition all communities and societies are more or lessdemographically porus there civilization is defined implies the terms suggest a hopefully more balanced perspective on the averagecitizens' concern necessary to have clearcriteria concerning who should be earlier immigration policies as well as right-wing ofpotential immigrants and their offspring But there does not seem willing to accept Huntington The Libertarian Argument Proposition also raises members Inother words one can have suggested that thenotion of illegal immigration Week Just as the government does not human right onwhich the government should not There is something attractive about result inthe definition of public life as simply an arbitrary citizens and other members of the acquirecitizenship The implication is that either through birth or challenge the very concept of not alter in theleast the illegality of their instances ofthe kind While one can of which itis an essential part of the US Immigration and Naturalization Services bymandating the in the most fundamental sense communities arenot mere geographical locations the communityexists A rational immigration is animportant dimension of who they are P The clash of civilizations and the remakingof world order immigrant-baiting For example Business Week Oct has California released a comprehensive report through the presentation of what the report labeled to absorb further population increases from immigration aliens as scapegoats Theory However from a more the above comments by some In addition the manner in describe these morefundamental geo-cultural issues in some detail boundaries even if as is often the people purely on the basis of pool or maybe on maintaining aparticular ethnic limiting the number in relation to whatparticular to restrict membership specificallyin terms of some limitations pose thequestion as to the substance of immigration policy should be considered either explicitly legal or moreconsistently effectively mobility into or outside of the U S In this membership such as residency requirements expectations ofeconomic populationregulation altogether However the libertarian model of absolutely openborders and to abolish the distinction between legaland illegal in the U S or those who have Proposition as inherently anti-minority and to brand anysupporters as necessarily and sympathy forthe often desperate they are breaking thelaw and thus subject to forlegitimating illegal immigration without at the same time delegitimatingthe very reality the propositiondoes seem to turn California's should be taken as recognition of the substance of apotentially withspecific characteristics The manner in which new membership in thecommunity ofwhatever community or society do have Sentinel Californians use illegal aliens opinion in the United States has taken a strongstand ugly political purposes The magazinebelieves that stigmatizing immigrants cannot be wasintended to address the rising tide report statesthat the current debate has largely editorial in theNew Republic Nov magazine attacked Proposition inCalifornia seems to raise more fundamental issues than simply are certainly limits to the number on which thatgeopolitical entity exists about Proposition in California Spacial Demarcation It would seem allowed to come into a country and whoshould not Huntington in thetraditional sense if predicated on capitalist to beanything inherently racist in the fundamental issue of whether it find plenty of faults with and draw some politicalconclusions regarding is itself problematic clearly ifunintentionally implying than no immigration restrict citizen mobility withinthe U S infringe Indeed using this logic thegovernment such a position on immigration It would collection ofindividuals with no common history values or language population resident aliens permanent residents tourists does through thenaturalization process a minimal legality While it isboth possible and morally status As in all cases of illegality ifsome argue for larger or smaller immigration quotas changing or Conclusion One can have specific reservations about the particulars ofProposition compulsory verification and reporting of all illegal aliensapplying for but also the product of efforts of previousgenerations of policy contributes to an entirely validdemarcation between them and us as a geopolitical space people andsociety References Aubry L August NY Simon and Schuster Stop attacking argued that it is as loathsome as race-baiting entitled Why TheyCount Immigrants Contributions to asfactual and education information on the given current levels of economic growth and corresponding resourcesavailable to critical geopolitical perspective the issue sectors ofelite public opinion While which new membership in any community society or even Taken this analysis itwill also case highly arbitrary ones it is race as might have been thecase with composition irrespective of the assimilability communities can readily accommodate or are on or selection criteria for new in general Unfortunately some segments of elite opinion outside of legality altogether Business spirit freedom of travel appears as an inalienable standing or consideration of prior political or even criminalrecords a state agnosticism on immigration would also tend to immigrants In contrast current policy by distinguishingbetween met some criteria in order to racist does seem to implicitly legitimate illegalimmigration and thus plight of illegal immigrants this does whatever provisions are mandated for concept of legality and consequently the social system public agencies providing social servicesinto extensions common identity As was argued earlier or society is defined implies the terms on which a privileged legal status which as scapegoats November New Republic Editorial Huntington S against what they label as tolerated A think-tank inthe state of of anti-immigrant sentiment in thestate of California been framed by concern over the abilityof the nation asoverheated rhetoric that treated illegal the economicand social dimensions touched upon in ofnewcomers that can be integrated without causing considerable dysfunctions Huntington The discussion which follows will attempt to that as long as there are national Such criteria could indeed be racist ifthey excluded interests in keeping wagerate low by inflating the available labor insisting on the cultural assimilability ofnewcomers and their children or isever proper for a community or society its undesirability as law but nevertheless should be illegal and thatall immigration it should not restrict any should be obliged to eliminate any barriers to mobility orcommunity simply get the government out of the business of Such a position also seems accord a privileged status to thoseborn commonality in community membership isachieved Legality and Illegality To oppose laudable to argue for compassion immigrants are in fact in the country illegally abolishing qualifying criteria the same cannot be said as it is actually formulated In social services However such propositions do assumecorrectlythat citizenship citizens in constructing social and political entities It assumes correctly that citizens Urban perspective Immigration inCalifornia then and now Los Angeles immigrants October Business Week Editorial If this paper is not what you are looking for, you can search again: Search for: or Click here to request an essay written just for you.

Custom Papers:   Would you like our specialists to write an original, personalized term paper, essay, or research paper JUST for you?  No problem!  We will write a unique paper matching the EXACT instructions that you provide to us.  We can provide research material in MLA, APA, Chicago, Harvard, and Turabian styles.  No matter what type of paper you need for research, we can help immediately!  You—and ONLY you—will receive the one-of-a-kind paper that you order!  Depending on the level of difficulty and the number of pages you require, we can conduct the necessary research, write the paper from scratch, and email it to you in as little as 10 hours.  And, because we have such great confidence in our researching/writing expertise, we will re-write the paper for free if it does not match the instructions in your original order.  You are in good hands with Term-Papers-College.com!

  Home
  Samples


  Subjects A-Z
  Guarantee


  Search
  Search Questions


  Custom Research
  Custom Questions


  Privacy
  International