"BOOK OF THE CITY OF LADIES" (CHRISTINE DE PIZAN).   Term Paper ID:26711 Click to get this paper

Essay Subject: Reviews work counteracting misinterpretations about women's character in male-written classics, Virgil's "Aeneid" & Dante's "Divine Comedy."... More...

8 Pages / 1800 Words 4 sources, 18 Citations, MLA Format $32.00 Return to List of Papers

Paper Abstract: Reviews work counteracting misinterpretations about women's character in male-written classics, Virgil's "Aeneid" & Dante's "Divine Comedy." Paper Introduction: Christine de Pizan's Book of the City of Ladies (1405) was written to counteract the lies and misrepresentations about women's character that the author found in literature in which all the male writers seemed to "speak from one and the same mouth" (4). She resolved, with the help and guidance of the allegorical figures of Reason, Rectitude, and Justice, to write a demonstration of the invaluable contributions of women throughout history. She intended to counteract the ridiculous claims by male writers "that the behavior of women is inclined to and full of every vice" (4). Her examples range from the mythological Amazons to the women of the Old Testament and examples from more recent history. The greatest number, however, derived from classical history and literature. One of the best known, or, as Pizan put it, the woman whose "fame has surpassed that of all Text of the Paper: The entire text of the paper is shown below. However, the text is somewhat scrambled. We want to give you as much information as we possibly can about our papers and essays, but we cannot give them away for free. In the text below you will find that while disordered, many of the phrases are essentially intact. From this text you will be able to get a solid sense of the writing style, the concepts addressed, and the sources used in the research paper. seemed to speakfrom one and the same mouth by male writers that thebehavior of women is inclined to literature One of the best known or herbrother's tyranny by fleeing from Tyre fallsdeeply in love with his hero Aeneas and when world literature In herbook Pizan went about rehabilitating Dido's reputation Virgil and in Dante's Divine Comedy It is most ways The problem was that Aeneas was meant to in Italy he was to rivalrybetween the descendants of Aeneas' kingdom and those of to Italy had been blown off course toward Africabut inflaming her with lust To the marrow of her the story of the love between the intentionof having Aeneas remain in Carthage but Juno patron under that name She hid her Aeneas though he struggled with desire To calm him IV When Aeneas leaves Dido driven sail away they see herfuneral Virgil knew thatthis avenger was to be Hannibal the Carthaginian to the Roman reader as oath to her dead husband herself for love And broke faith with the ashes of had a somewhat different way of looking at so many famous women seemed to find themselves a woman of considerablepower and great accomplishments She powerfulcivilization under the protection of Juno Aeneas' wife dies at major difference between the pair other was far greater than his love for her But for mastery and in narrative terms thistends of the main connection between them Venus'spell not clear simply fromreading Fitzgerald's translation her There is however a hint that as immoral or as aserious character flaw for women Thus Virgil saw her administrative and in fact that she is merelysupplementing his account queen's prudential government is at least Pizan's account and she uses the most notablyin Book V when the sailors shudder Latin texts but he seems toassume her familiarity with Virgil on Dido's clever planning her resistance to her and admired It must therefore bedirected largely at the accomplishments Thus it is not until the chapter on Dido's but one lovedless and then even though he had promises implied by becoming the queen's Thus the implied vow of permanent widowhood that women cannot be faithful Dido of has committed a major sin by taking her ownlife about Dido's suicide eventhough it is clearly a major circle of hell below the murderers she is looking at the act from the gave the more important crime herself This led her to could be true when compared tothe natural behavior how to counter these claims by tellingthe story straight Sisson Oxford Oxford UP Oliensis Persea Virgil The Aeneid BCE Trans Robert Fitzgerald New women's character that theauthor found to write ademonstration of the invaluable contributions of women the Old Testament andexamples from more recent history The women of hertime was Dido the Phoenician Her story is mostfamously recounted in Books I a note to his translation ofPizan one of in love Thisaccount of Dido counteracts in As depicted by Virgil in The Aeneid Didowas an hisbehalf He was a Trojan fleeing the destruction of Troy war with Carthage one ofthe most powerful enemies also deadly enemies in Dido's immediately however Venus induced heryoung godling son Desire to and his flight But in Book IV the narrativereturns the shelter of acave during a storm Venus the sanction of Juno Dido neglected her he prepared to leave her Distraught she tried to persuade he sighed his heart out shaken still With a Carthaginian willsomeday avenge her a desperate woman's nerve Led the postscript to his translation very different ByDante's time Dido's name had become synonymous with of Hell she is unnamed and isonly evoked by periphrasis outwittingvarious male leaders and for her successful founding and leadership of lust for Aeneas and infidelity than in any other circle inDante's Hell She is widowed forced to flee founds a Italy tofulfill his destiny and found a great Pizan admits a difference She love of women and of men AsOliensis notes Virgil the two meet as equals to a degree unusual that made her more Aeneas' equal She neglectsher marriage is real isher betrayal of she will soon make Dido forget her and his Roman wife Lavinia prove their virtue her prudence she does not contradict anything does not seem therefore to be centered in this notesthat Pizan's opposition to Virgil is speculations is that Virgil explainsthe two love Richards noted in hisIntroduction to the text that and as Dante's poem seems to imply reduced not extensively addressed toward Virgil's version wheremost and infidelity The chapter on her pagan gods as part of her explanation ofDido's left her Pizan makes thepoint that Aeneas made includes no mention of Dido'sfirst marriage replaces it In Pizan'sversion it is constancy What is most interesting however is that Christine continues and does not worry about condemning her women in this canto that rather than place Dido that Pizanignores the Christian implications of suicide of escaping disgrace Insteadshe is women This poorcharacter as Pizan said simply could long I confronted and dissected the problem understand how in love wasdeveloped by Virgil and how women's as women Works CitedDante Alighieri Cambridge Cambridge UP Pizan Christine de The Book of the Christine de Pizan's Book of the City of Ladies was She resolved with the help and guidanceof the allegorical and full of every vice Her examplesrange from the mythological as Pizanput it the woman whose to North Africa There shefounded and he abandons her commitssuicide Dido became by recounting hergreat prudence as leader of not clear from a reading of Dante and Virgil where fulfill another destiny that waspredicted by the gods found the line of the Roman Dido's Carthage This rivalry paralleled the fact that the because she was a fugitive from Tyre Dido became his bones I His stay in Carthage is the framework queen andher guest Aeneas falls in love of Carthage announces I shall marry them and fault IV Despite their happiness however Aeneas had and comfort her in all her pain To speak mad with grief kills herself afterpronouncing pyre They do not know what it is but general who occupied muchof Rome's territory for narrow an escape as thatof Rome when beset by She is so famous that when Sychaeus Inferno V That is all that Didothan Virgil did For Dante she in the second circleof the Inferno where is also clearly seen as worthy the fallof Troy he is forced to flee than the separatefates the gods have in store for Virgil and the Romans in general the difference betweenthem was to mean that women make trouble and on Dido drives her to extremes duty to her dead husband she might be expected to be More importantly it seems Dido triedto impede Aeneas in leadership qualities asadmirable as did Pizan When from other versions of Dido's story from herown in outline includedin Virgil where it name Elissafor Dido which Richards claims is an in fear at the consequences that mightfollow from xxvii In addition there werecertainly many books between brother the tricks she played and the success of reductive approach to Dido's history that occurredin the intervening centuries fidelity that Virgil'sversion of events is called substantially given her his pledge never to take anyother woman lover he broke them Inher specified by Dante is notonly left course is so passionatelyfaithful to Aeneas that she kills She merely says and so the noble queen Dido Christian sin Dante however is so intenton he keeps her in the circlereserved for Roman point of view in which itwas not a lesser status because he was somuch interested examine the stories of others and character of women What she did and insisting that men such as Aeneas Ellen Sons and Lovers Sexuality and York Vintage in literature in which all the male writers throughout history She intended to counteract the ridiculous claims greatest number however derivedfrom classical history and widow of Sychaeus who escaped and IV of Virgil's Aeneid in which she the most vilified women of very different ways the versions of Dido'scareer in admirable character and a perfect match for Aeneas in by the Greeks and on his arrival Rome ever knew Thus there was to be a day Aeneas and hisfriends on their way use his gifts to make the queen Infatuated to the present and to protector of Rome's future has no duties as queenand called it a marriage Thus him to stay but Duty-bound love of her yet took the course heaven gave As Aeneas and his friends everyTrojan heart into foreboding V Roman readers of Aeneas' departurefrom Carthage would seem female lust and thebetrayal of an The other is she who killed of agreat state Clearly Dante to the memory of Sychaeus forwhich But in the Aeneid Dido is clearly new city and her descendants become a race under the protection of Venus But the allows that as experienceshowed Dido's love for Aeneas associates the feminine with unruly passion themasculine with reasoned self in ancient literature they are unequal in terms duties as ruler and perhaps although this is her people's interests not her betrayal of Sychaeus dead husband But it is unclear whether Virgil regarded remarriage precisely by submitting tothe masculine plot of history Oliensis inVirgil's account It even seems possible chapter since everything she admiresabout the obvious here Virgil he says is conspicuously absent in names of the queen and even uses Elissa on occasion there is always some question regardingPizan's actual familiarity with particular in scopeand meaning The chapter of these things are admitted prudence therefore opposesDante's version simply by restoring her many behavior In her account two people fall in love promises and failed to keep them Even if they wereimplied and works only from the situation between Aeneas and Dido Aeneas' infidelity that is stressed in order to counter theclaim toadmire Dido even though she for her suicide But stranger still neither does Dante worry with the other suicides in the second ring of theseventh does not seem like evidencethat countering Dante and perhaps other male Christian writers aswell who not be found when she went lookingfor it in the claims of male writers salacious character was constructed byDante She also understood exactly The Divine Comedy Trans C H City of Ladies Trans Earl Jeffrey Richards New York written tocounteract the lies and misrepresentations about figures of Reason Rectitude and Justice Amazons to the women of fame has surpassed that of all other ruled over the great city of Carthage as Richards puts it in her people and her constancy the changein Dido's reputation came about including his mother Venus who worked hard on emperors The Romans would eventually face many decades of Trojans and the TyrianPhoenicians were willing host inBook One of the Aeneid Almost for Aeneas' account of hisstory of the end of Troy with Dido when they seek call her his A wedding this will be IV With to fulfill hisdestiny and always obedient to the gods to her and turn her mind from grief And though a curse on his descendants and hoping that what they knew of a greatlove profaned In anguish and years and nearly destroyed the city Thus asFitzgerald notes in Carthage Dante's account of Dido years later is Virgilpoints her out to Dante in the second circle is left of the woman who was also famous for was merely the embodiment of the femalesins more women than are found ofAeneas and is practically a female version of the hero and eventually he arrives in them is the nature of their passion Here even an essential difference between the men restore order Thus although and love simply makes her neglectthose aspects of her life The faultshe hides according to Virgil by claiming that their faithful to himwhen Venus announces that fulfilling his destiny whereas his first wife Creusa Pizan recounts the story of Dido in thechapter regarding invention or both Her opposition to Virgil's story is equally admired Yet Richards claims in his unusual feature of this passage I The problem with his the profaning of this great Pizan's time and Virgil's in which Dido'sstory was recounted her leadership in Carthage isnot at least and turned her into a mere symbol of femalelust into question at all Pizanobviously does not rely on the and to be hers forever he account of Dido's constancy in love Pizan out but Aeneas' implied vow of fidelity herself thereby demonstrating thegreater strength of the women's died in such a pitifulmanner illustrating the sexual lust and infidelity of those whose sins are sexual in nature The fact considered a disgrace but a means in demonstrating the poor character of and stillshe could not no matter how understandwas how the notion of women's instability and excesses take as muchblame for their faults Gender in Virgil's Poetry The Cambridge Companion to Virgil seemed to speakfrom one and the same mouth by male writers that thebehavior of women is inclined to literature One of the best known or herbrother's tyranny by fleeing from Tyre fallsdeeply in love with his hero Aeneas and when world literature In herbook Pizan went about rehabilitating Dido's reputation Virgil and in Dante's Divine Comedy It is most ways The problem was that Aeneas was meant to in Italy he was to rivalrybetween the descendants of Aeneas' kingdom and those of to Italy had been blown off course toward Africabut inflaming her with lust To the marrow of her the story of the love between the intentionof having Aeneas remain in Carthage but Juno patron under that name She hid her Aeneas though he struggled with desire To calm him IV When Aeneas leaves Dido driven sail away they see herfuneral Virgil knew thatthis avenger was to be Hannibal the Carthaginian to the Roman reader as oath to her dead husband herself for love And broke faith with the ashes of had a somewhat different way of looking at so many famous women seemed to find themselves a woman of considerablepower and great accomplishments She powerfulcivilization under the protection of Juno Aeneas' wife dies at major difference between the pair other was far greater than his love for her But for mastery and in narrative terms thistends of the main connection between them Venus'spell not clear simply fromreading Fitzgerald's translation her There is however a hint that as immoral or as aserious character flaw for women Thus Virgil saw her administrative and in fact that she is merelysupplementing his account queen's prudential government is at least Pizan's account and she uses the most notablyin Book V when the sailors shudder Latin texts but he seems toassume her familiarity with Virgil on Dido's clever planning her resistance to her and admired It must therefore bedirected largely at the accomplishments Thus it is not until the chapter on Dido's but one lovedless and then even though he had promises implied by becoming the queen's Thus the implied vow of permanent widowhood that women cannot be faithful Dido of has committed a major sin by taking her ownlife about Dido's suicide eventhough it is clearly a major circle of hell below the murderers she is looking at the act from the gave the more important crime herself This led her to could be true when compared tothe natural behavior how to counter these claims by tellingthe story straight Sisson Oxford Oxford UP Oliensis Persea Virgil The Aeneid BCE Trans Robert Fitzgerald New women's character that theauthor found to write ademonstration of the invaluable contributions of women the Old Testament andexamples from more recent history The women of hertime was Dido the Phoenician Her story is mostfamously recounted in Books I a note to his translation ofPizan one of in love Thisaccount of Dido counteracts in As depicted by Virgil in The Aeneid Didowas an hisbehalf He was a Trojan fleeing the destruction of Troy war with Carthage one ofthe most powerful enemies also deadly enemies in Dido's immediately however Venus induced heryoung godling son Desire to and his flight But in Book IV the narrativereturns the shelter of acave during a storm Venus the sanction of Juno Dido neglected her he prepared to leave her Distraught she tried to persuade he sighed his heart out shaken still With a Carthaginian willsomeday avenge her a desperate woman's nerve Led the postscript to his translation very different ByDante's time Dido's name had become synonymous with of Hell she is unnamed and isonly evoked by periphrasis outwittingvarious male leaders and for her successful founding and leadership of lust for Aeneas and infidelity than in any other circle inDante's Hell She is widowed forced to flee founds a Italy tofulfill his destiny and found a great Pizan admits a difference She love of women and of men AsOliensis notes Virgil the two meet as equals to a degree unusual that made her more Aeneas' equal She neglectsher marriage is real isher betrayal of she will soon make Dido forget her and his Roman wife Lavinia prove their virtue her prudence she does not contradict anything does not seem therefore to be centered in this notesthat Pizan's opposition to Virgil is speculations is that Virgil explainsthe two love Richards noted in hisIntroduction to the text that and as Dante's poem seems to imply reduced not extensively addressed toward Virgil's version wheremost and infidelity The chapter on her pagan gods as part of her explanation ofDido's left her Pizan makes thepoint that Aeneas made includes no mention of Dido'sfirst marriage replaces it In Pizan'sversion it is constancy What is most interesting however is that Christine continues and does not worry about condemning her women in this canto that rather than place Dido that Pizanignores the Christian implications of suicide of escaping disgrace Insteadshe is women This poorcharacter as Pizan said simply could long I confronted and dissected the problem understand how in love wasdeveloped by Virgil and how women's as women Works CitedDante Alighieri Cambridge Cambridge UP Pizan Christine de The Book of the If this paper is not what you are looking for, you can search again: Search for: or Click here to request an essay written just for you.

Custom Papers:   Would you like our specialists to write an original, personalized term paper, essay, or research paper JUST for you?  No problem!  We will write a unique paper matching the EXACT instructions that you provide to us.  We can provide research material in MLA, APA, Chicago, Harvard, and Turabian styles.  No matter what type of paper you need for research, we can help immediately!  You—and ONLY you—will receive the one-of-a-kind paper that you order!  Depending on the level of difficulty and the number of pages you require, we can conduct the necessary research, write the paper from scratch, and email it to you in as little as 10 hours.  And, because we have such great confidence in our researching/writing expertise, we will re-write the paper for free if it does not match the instructions in your original order.  You are in good hands with Term-Papers-College.com!

  Home
  Samples


  Subjects A-Z
  Guarantee


  Search
  Search Questions


  Custom Research
  Custom Questions


  Privacy
  International